You Are My Arsenal

Main Menu

  • About
  • Latest News
    • General
    • Match Previews
    • Transfer Window
  • Analysis
    • Players
    • Post Match Review
  • Contact

logo

  • About
  • Latest News
    • General
    • Match Previews
    • Transfer Window
  • Analysis
    • mikel-arteta-arsenal-coach-tactical-analysis

      Tactical Analysis: What the Scotland friendlies tell us about Arsenal’s defensive tactics ...

      September 2, 2021
      0
    • arsenal-preseason-2021-analysis

      Tactical Analysis: What the Scotland Friendlies tell us about Arsenal's Style of ...

      August 12, 2021
      2
    • Defending from the front - How Arsenal has improved their defense

      March 26, 2021
      0
    • arsenal-tottenham-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      Arsenal's Derby Redemption

      March 15, 2021
      1
    • leicester-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      How Arsenal rounded off the perfect week

      March 1, 2021
      2
    • west-brom-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      How Arsenal dismantled West Brom - Tactical Analysis

      January 4, 2021
      0
    • arsenal-chelsea-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      How Arsenal dispatched Chelsea

      December 28, 2020
      0
    • everton-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      Tactical Analysis: What went wrong for Arsenal vs Everton?

      December 21, 2020
      0
    • tottenham-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      Breaking Down Arsenal's Woes vs Tottenham - Tactical Analysis

      December 8, 2020
      0
    • Players
    • Post Match Review
  • Contact
  • Arsenal vs Atletico Match Preview: Gunners aim to extend perfect Champions League start

  • Fulham 0–1 Arsenal: Three Things We Learned as the Gunners Go Top

  • Riccardo Calafiori: Arsenal’s Shape-Shifting Soul

  • Arsenal’s Right-Side Blueprint: How Saka, Ødegaard, and Timber Are Driving the Attack

  • What the First Seven Matches Really Tell Us About Arsenal’s Contenders’ Credentials

General
Home›General›Would Arsenal Be Making the Same Mistake By Hiring Marcelino?

Would Arsenal Be Making the Same Mistake By Hiring Marcelino?

By Michael Price
December 13, 2019
965
1
Share:
marcelino-arsenal-manager-opinion

“He’s a good coach.” The words of Jon Driscoll, host of La Liga Weekly, appearing on The Gooner Talk’s Managerial Tactical Breakdown show. But the question remains, would Marcelino be just another Emery?

It is true though, the Spaniard is a very good coach, he took a Valencia side bereft of confidence and identity back into the Champions League during his first season. A feat which Arsenal fans will be desperate for the coach who takes over at the Emirates to achieve. So why then is there such a trend to immediately disregard Marcelino as a credible option?

Firstly, communication. Marcelino, whilst learning, is not an English-speaking coach. In fact, rather unlike Emery, Marcelino has never managed outside of his home nation. Whilst his coaching methods and style are clearly visible, especially during his last two spells, the simple fact that he would struggle to communicate coherently to the many non-Spanish speakers, is plenty to turn fans off from the Spaniard.

During the final years under Wenger a giant wedge separated the fan base, that chasm was united under Emery except the unanimous view was not one of support and backing, but one of distain and frustration. The “Good Ebening” meme became a regular feature in both mainstream and social media and it would be unwise of the Arsenal hierarchy to risk a coach whose communication was once again at the forefront of possible reservations.

Secondly is the style. Emery arrived at Arsenal with a misunderstood view of his coaching. Thought of as a ‘defensive’ coach by many, it quickly surprised and even enraged many Gunner supporters to see the continual stream of defensive errors and mistakes leading to dropped points. In fact, Emery is better known for a counter-attacking style, bled from a more reserved game of allowing opposition teams to make mistakes before administering an interception or tackle to then hit sides on the break.

Having witnessed 22 years of possession-based, free-flowing football this style was met with much animosity. And it is a style which the aforementioned Marcelino does have some mirrored features of. The Spaniard does like his teams to hit strongly on the counter. Marcelino’s success in his first season equipping this style was helped by the situation in which he found his club. Less regarded as one of the powerhouses of Spanish football, Valencia were a sleeping giant, vulnerable to almost any Primera Division opposition. Can you see the parallels yet?

However, unlike an Arsenal side ill-equipped to implement tactics of this nature, the likes of Rodrigo and Goncalo Guedes thrived on it. Teams were stunned by Valencia’s ferocity and power and often caught with a false sense of security. Were Marcelino to take the reins at Arsenal, it is much less likely the playing staff suitable for this effort would be available to him.

There is however separation from Emery. Marcelino has improved the defensive side of Valencia’s game and not simply with acquisitions but by improving existing talent. Former Arsenal bulldozer Gabriel Paulista was a shrewd signing and became an example of the Spaniard’s impact on defensive players. The Brazilian, often criticised for his rashness in England became a dependable figure for the Mestella faithful. Ruben Vezo and Jeison Murillo often partnered Gabriel and to great effect keeping 12 clean sheets across the 17/18 La Liga season.

A further difference is noticed in the formation which Marcelino deploys. Whilst Emery has opted for a plethora of formations from a 4-3-3 to incorporating a midfield diamond, Marcelino used a cut and dry flat 4-4-2. This allowed for solid recovery in the middle of the park to then turn quick on the counter with the wide players feeding the forwards quickly to hurt opposition teams.

Arsenal fans have seen both Alexandre Lacazette and Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang play together in differing circumstances, with differing outcomes. However, there is a large majority who would agree that when operating as a front two, this is when they are at their least effective. Both suit the sole striker role with support from wide positions to create the optimum balance and chance creation type – especially in the Gabonese forward’s case.

The arrival of Marcelino would almost certainly spell the end for at least one or even two of those front men were they not willing to once again play in a system not akin to their preference.

To summarise, we end where we began, there is no doubting that Marcelino is a “good coach.” In fact, a very good coach. However, the circumstances which he would find himself in at the Emirates are just far too specific with a supporter base lacking enough patience to allow for a slow integration and shift to the Spaniard’s methods. The alternative is a move to Merseyside, whilst the communication will be a challenge, maybe the affordance of time and openness to a coach of his talents and style would make him better suited to the Everton squad.

TagsAFCArsenalArsenal FCArsene WengerAubameyangHead CoachlacazetteManagerMarcelinoUnai Emery
Previous Article

Well deserved: Outstanding performances show starlet is ...

Next Article

Football punditry in the age of social ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related articles More from author

  • Match Previews

    Match Preview: Crystal Palace v Arsenal; Last Stop on #PROJECT24

    October 27, 2018
    By Michael Price
  • Crystal Palace vs Arsenal Premier League clash at Selhurst Park.
    Match Previews

    Match Preview Crystal Palace v Arsenal: Premier League Clash at Selhurst Park

    December 20, 2024
    By Michael Price
  • watford-arsenal-premier-league-2019-2020-tactical-analysis
    Talking Tactics

    Premier League 2019/20: Watford vs Arsenal – Tactical Analysis

    September 17, 2019
    By Michael Price
  • Claude-Maurice-Winger-Arsenal-Transfer-Summer-Analysis
    Players

    Tactical Player Profile: Alexis Claude-Maurice

    June 19, 2019
    By Michael Price
  • arsenal-norwich-premier-league-2021-2022-five-things
    Post Match Review

    Five Things We Learned from Arsenal vs Norwich

    September 13, 2021
    By Rasmus Pabst
  • Match Previews

    Match Preview: Arsenal v Newcastle United; Starting off 2016 on the Right Foot

    January 1, 2016
    By Michael Price

1 comment

  1. Gunnerpete 13 December, 2019 at 11:19 Log in to Reply

    From now on Arsenal should only hire managers who speak clear English. Emery tried but no one understood him. He, like Arsene forgot the basic rule of football that made AFC the most feared club in the world, ‘ don’t concede and you don’t lose’ .

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Match Previews

    Match Preview: Arsenal v West Ham; Gunners Look to Kick Off Title Contention

  • Match Previews

    FA CUP Semi-Final Match Preview: She Said It’s For The Arsenal And We’re Going To Wembley

  • Match Previews

    Match Preview: Arsenal v Wolves

About Author

Michael Price

View all posts

Follow us

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
© YouAreMyArsenal. All rights reserved.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
You can revoke your consent any time using the revoke consent button.