You Are My Arsenal

Main Menu

  • About
  • Latest News
    • General
    • Match Previews
    • Transfer Window
  • Analysis
    • Players
    • Post Match Review
  • Contact

logo

  • About
  • Latest News
    • General
    • Match Previews
    • Transfer Window
  • Analysis
    • mikel-arteta-arsenal-coach-tactical-analysis

      Tactical Analysis: What the Scotland friendlies tell us about Arsenal’s defensive tactics ...

      September 2, 2021
      0
    • arsenal-preseason-2021-analysis

      Tactical Analysis: What the Scotland Friendlies tell us about Arsenal's Style of ...

      August 12, 2021
      2
    • Defending from the front - How Arsenal has improved their defense

      March 26, 2021
      0
    • arsenal-tottenham-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      Arsenal's Derby Redemption

      March 15, 2021
      1
    • leicester-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      How Arsenal rounded off the perfect week

      March 1, 2021
      2
    • west-brom-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      How Arsenal dismantled West Brom - Tactical Analysis

      January 4, 2021
      0
    • arsenal-chelsea-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      How Arsenal dispatched Chelsea

      December 28, 2020
      0
    • everton-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      Tactical Analysis: What went wrong for Arsenal vs Everton?

      December 21, 2020
      0
    • tottenham-arsenal-premier-league-2020-2021-tactical-analysis

      Breaking Down Arsenal's Woes vs Tottenham - Tactical Analysis

      December 8, 2020
      0
    • Players
    • Post Match Review
  • Contact
  • Fulham 0–1 Arsenal: Three Things We Learned as the Gunners Go Top

  • Riccardo Calafiori: Arsenal’s Shape-Shifting Soul

  • Arsenal’s Right-Side Blueprint: How Saka, Ødegaard, and Timber Are Driving the Attack

  • What the First Seven Matches Really Tell Us About Arsenal’s Contenders’ Credentials

  • Three Things We Learned as Arsenal Beat West Ham to Go Top of the Premier League

General
Home›General›The Inscrutable Arsène Wenger

The Inscrutable Arsène Wenger

By Michael Price
September 3, 2015
633
9
Share:

The close of the summer transfer period on Tuesday prompted an incredulous response from many Arsenal supporters. How, they asked, could Arsenal state aspirations to compete for the Premier League title and neglect summer transfers?

The disconnect seems all the more pronounced in light of the activity of other title aspirants, particularly Manchester City and Manchester United and, to a lesser extent, Chelsea. They were three of the top four spenders, on a net basis, in the league, while Arsenal ranked 15th.

To broaden and intensify the contrast: Arsenal were the only club in the top-five European leagues not to recruit a senior outfield player during this transfer period.

This is seen as a clear indication of a character flaw in manager Arsène Wenger.

Reasons for the uproar

I think this misguided response comes down to three factors:

  1. Our own ignorance of the arcane environment of football transfers
  2. Our lazy equation of one man with the activity of a multifaceted enterprise
  3. Wenger’s remarkable ability, despite years in the public eye, to defy assumptions and expectations

 

I’ve written about the bizarre world of football transfers before, so instead of restating my case here, I’ll just direct you to a piece on my personal blog, “Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Even Small Crowds.” The main point is that football transfers don’t have the characteristics of any transaction we’re familiar with – and they certainly aren’t as straightforward as popular computer games make them seem.

Even the term “transfer market” creates a false impression, because it suggests a large pool of transparent transactions that can be compared to each other. That’s not the case for the few, murky, discrete exchanges of footballers and money among European clubs.

My article “Arsenal, Arsène Wenger, and the Cult of Personality” examines the second factor, arguing that the equation of individual managers with clubs is lazy, misleading, and convenient, in the sense that it allows me as an individual to criticize a public figure based on the way I would have acted in similar circumstances.

An exceptional figure

It’s the third factor I want to look at here. Accepting that Wenger plays the dominant role in Arsenal’s acquisition of players, the manager has shown instincts that so few of us can understand, let alone summon.

To wit: When the next summer transfer period closes, Wenger will be in the final year of his contract. Yet in this penultimate opportunity for a major expenditure, he held back, or at least endorsed the approach of holding back. How many of us, knowing we could be out the door in the medium term, would have done the same?

Instead, the manager and his colleagues made just one acquisition at the first-team level. Even there, the move went against expectation. Arsenal paid Chelsea £10.9 million for 33-year-old goalkeeper Petr Cech. That’s the highest fee for a goalkeeper in Wenger’s tenure – Richard Wright’s transfer cost the club £6 million in 2001 – and certainly represents the largest proportion of any transfer period’s activity for a goalkeeper. (Transfer figures are from The Arsenal Report’s Transfer Centre.)

The remainder of Arsenal’s transfer activity involved younger players, part of the club’s clear effort to enhance the player development structure and personnel. Jeff Reine-Adelaïde, the 17-year-old acquisition from Lens, put in two eye-catching preseason performances with the first team, while his compatriots Yassin Fortune and Ismaël Bennacer have also been highly touted. In all, the club spent £3.3 million on five youngsters, the largest single outlay on youth team players in Wenger’s time at the club.

That suggests that, despite his age, Wenger continues to manage for the long-term, valuing the training and upbringing of talented youth. At the same time, he has eased his prior practice of cutting ties with players older than 30, extending the contracts of Tomás Rosicky and Mikel Arteta this summer and showing a willingness to let 31-year-old Mathieu Flamini’s contract run to term next summer.

Adaptation or image management?

This portrayal isn’t of a hidebound geriatric or a spendthrift. Wenger is making multiple adjustments, not least deploying a considerable amount of the club’s resources in the past two years, to move the club closer to its title rivals. He won’t ever match their spending because profligacy doesn’t suit his philosophy–if it did, he’d have left for Real Madrid in 2005–and because that’s not the club’s strategy.

What Wenger will do is see out his current contract and keep us all guessing about his subsequent plans. Whether this coyness is a deliberate ploy to stay in the public eye, to take some of the scrutiny off his players, to solidify his legacy, or to remain true to his nature, that’s all conjecture.

We may never fully understand Wenger’s motives or decisions, but it’s incredibly interesting to try. If those efforts don’t figure him out to our satisfaction, that’s more on us than it is on him. Might it just be more worthwhile to marvel at this extraordinary steward of an organization that means so much to so many?

TagsAFCArsenalArsenal FCArseneArsene WengerTransfersYou Are My ArsenalYouAreMyArsenal
Previous Article

Addressing the Mad Mad Mad World of ...

Next Article

Wilshere and Welbeck and the Way Back

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related articles More from author

  • burnley-arsenal-premier-league-19-20-scout-report
    Match Previews

    Arsenal Opposition Scout Report – Burnley

    January 31, 2020
    By First Team
  • Match Previews

    Match Preview: Arsenal v Olympique de Marseille; Champion’s League Match Day 3

    October 19, 2011
    By Michael Price
  • arsenal-west-ham-premier-league-2021-2022-three-things-match-review
    General

    YAMA Weekly Roundtable: January transfers, PL officiating, and Arsenal’s Player of 2021

    January 15, 2022
    By First Team
  • Granit-Xhaka-Arsenal-midfielder
    General

    The Redemption of Granit Xhaka

    January 24, 2020
    By First Team
  • Post Match Review

    Brentford 1-3 Arsenal: Three Things We Learned from a Commanding Comeback

    January 2, 2025
    By Michael Price
  • GeneralPost Match Review

    All’s Well That Ends Well

    May 14, 2012
    By Michael Price

9 comments

  1. joshuad 8 September, 2015 at 23:27 Log in to Reply

    wenger did the same thing in 2003; only bought a goalkeeper. result, arsenal went unbeaten and won the premier league.

    the difference between that team and the current one is that team was set; stacked with talent and plenty of depth. this one has needs, primarily another center forward if giroud gets injured or needs a break. theo is no center forward. he’s a good wide player in a 4-3-3 or a second striker when playing with a strike partner.

    leading the line alone? when has theo ever done well against a good team? when has he ever come on as the lone center forward and arsenal looked more threatening? contrarily, how many times has giroud come on for walcott and the overall play has instantaneously improved? it’s because one is a legit center forward and one is not.

    the failure to sign another center forward reminds me of the ’07-’08 season when rosicky went down and instead of bringing in another winger, wenger opted to play a striker (eduardo) and then a center mid (diaby) on the wing. both were disasters as neither contributed with competent wide play, although not their fault. we’ll see what happens this time.

    • 900ftGooner 9 September, 2015 at 02:41 Log in to Reply

      Thanks for reading and commenting.

  2. brian 3 September, 2015 at 17:44 Log in to Reply

    Agree! The man is so stubborn and only signed ozil and Alexis due to fan pressure. No one could convince me the signings man city made would not have strengthened Arsenal! Man utd did waste money but sneiderlin would have been a good signing for us. Benteke surely would have favored a move to Arsenal over Liverpool? There were plenty of options Wenger is just so out of touch with the transfer market is madness.

  3. brian 3 September, 2015 at 17:37 Log in to Reply

    We are the one club that needs a director of football. Wenger is a great coach and development manager but he is so far out of touch with the modern transfer market he is allowing us to fall behind when we should be pushing forward. We should have signed a top striker! A big midfielder like vierra! And another versatile defender. We cannot win the title with this missing. And it’s getting boring finishing top 4 and quarter final of champions league.

    • 900ftGooner 3 September, 2015 at 22:24 Log in to Reply

      I appreciate your reading it.

  4. Sean Williams 3 September, 2015 at 16:24 Log in to Reply

    This is such a silly article. The writer is living in a land only he understands and in his own head. Wenger is no longer benefiting the club he is hindering it.Suggesting supporters do not understand the reality of the transfer market must suggest other managers do not understand it either because every other manager in the top 5 Leagues has managed to locate players they need. All that really stops Wenger doing the same is hubris and arrogance.

    • Zee 3 September, 2015 at 19:02 Log in to Reply

      Yes. Let us instead do what Liverpool or United or Tottenham have done. That’ll work out real well. Oh wait, no it won’t.

      • 900ftGooner 3 September, 2015 at 22:25 Log in to Reply

        Thanks for reading and commenting.

    • 900ftGooner 3 September, 2015 at 22:23 Log in to Reply

      Thanks for reading.

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Newcastle attacking prowess
    AnalysisOpinionsPlayers

    Lessons from the North East: How Newcastle’s Attacking Prowess and Tactical Discipline Can Inspire Arsenal

  • General

    EPL Match Day 15: Arsenal v Aston Villa; Match Preview

  • Jurrien Timber rises above the Manchester United defense to score a crucial header for Arsenal in their 2-0 Premier League victory
    Post Match Review

    Three Things We Learned from Arsenal’s Latest Triumph Over Manchester United

About Author

Michael Price

View all posts

Follow us

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
© YouAreMyArsenal. All rights reserved.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
You can revoke your consent any time using the revoke consent button.